Three clavicles, focusing on the sternal end. The clavicle on the left is unfused (young), the middle clavicle has half a 'flake' and the the clavicle on the right is fully fused (mature)
The sternal ends of three clavicles, moving from unfused (young) to fully fused (developmentally mature)

Late-Fusing Epiphyses and the Ribs

Age-at-death estimations are most commonly made using the pubic symphysis and auricular surface of the pelvis. However, several other methods are also employed, especially when the pelvis is not recovered or is too damaged for analysis. These typically include:

  • Late-fusing epiphyses (for young individuals only)
  • Sternal ends of the ribs

Late-Fusing Epiphyses

The identification of young adults can be achieved via the observation of late-fusing epiphyses, including the sternal end of the clavicle and the iliac crest of the pelvis mentioned in the video. Other late-fusing epiphyses include the first and second sacral vertebrae (late teens to early twenties) and the spheno-occipital synchondrosis (before 18 years of age). Examining whether or not these epiphyses have fused can be useful in attempting to assess age-at-death from bones which otherwise look fully mature.

A pelvis with the fusion of the iliac crest epiphyses highlighted In this pelvis, the iliac crest epiphysis is in the process of fusing on to the pelvis. The area where the fusion line is still visible is highlighted in blue.

Sternal End of the Clavicle

Examining the sternal (more rounded end) of the clavicle can be particularly useful for assessing age-at-death in younger individuals. Not only does the clavicle tend to preserve well, but assessing the stage of this late-fusing epiphysis is relatively straight forward. There are only three stages of fusion:

  1. Unfused (<25 years of age)
  2. Partially fused (18-25 years of age)
  3. Fully fused (>30 years of age)

Stage one, where the sternal end shows no signs of fusion, maintains the billowing youthful surface previously described in earlier articles and videos. During stage two, the epiphysis, often referred to as a ‘flake’, begins fusing to the clavicle but does not yet cover the entire sternal surface. The age of fusion can be quite variable, however, nearly all individuals reach stage three, where the sternal end of the clavicle has completely fused before age 30. This means that once the clavicle has reached stage three, the clavicle cannot help us to make more specific age-at-death estimations beyond 30 years old or above.

Three clavicles, showing an unfused, partially fused and fully fused sternal end The developmental stages of the sternal end of the clavicle; unfused (left), partially fused (middle) and fused (right).

Sternal End of the Ribs

Examining the ribs at the point where they articulate in the front of the body with sternum can be a useful method for age-at-death estimation. İşcan et al. (1984a, b, 1985) devised an eight-phase system of age estimation from the sternal end of the fourth rib in particular. However, the 3rd and fifth rib can be substituted when the fourth has not been preserved.

The sternal ends of ribs from younger individuals show a joint surface with a slight depression and clear, sharp margins. As an individual ages, the margins of the ribs become more irregular and the depression of the joint surface deepens, beginning to resemble a pit. In an older individual, the joint surface has formed a pronounced pit, the margins are quite irregular and the surrounding cartilage may even have started to ossify (or become bone).

Although commonly used in forensic contexts, this method of assessing age-at-death is less practical in archaeological contexts, where the fourth rib is rarely well enough preserved to identify or analyse for age-at-death estimation. Further, this method has been shown to be highly variable, particularly after 30 years of age.

Take a look at the 3D model of a pelvis with late-fusing epiphyses. Understanding the placement of these epiphyses is important not only for accurate age-at-death estimations but also so that they are not mistaken for trauma or pathology.

Now that you’ve learned about several methods to generate age-at-death estimates for adults, move on to the next step to learn about stature, which is another important feature for making identifications from skeletal remains.

Share this article:

This article is from the free online course:

Forensic Archaeology and Anthropology

Durham University