Engaging with primary sources: 'motivation to fight'
Now it’s your turn to become the historian – we invite you to go and explore some of our primary sources which are available on the web.
The following primary sources relate to the video you have just watched. Don’t worry you don’t have to read them all!
We hope that having explored some of these materials, that you would use the comments section below to share your thoughts on the resources you found most interesting and engaging. Your fellow learners will benefit from reading what you found particularly noteworthy.
As I’m sure you are aware, these are just a sample of a much broader range of sources available and may complement or contradict some of the themes or ideas raised in this or other videos. These sources are here for you to draw upon across the course and will inform your contributions to course discussions.
For guidance on using primary sources refer back to Step 2.5.
Please note that some of the resources may not be optimised for mobile or tablet viewing, and may be best accessed through a PC or laptop.
In some of the final steps of this week, you will find a guide to further reading and a broad list of web resources relevant to this week’s theme.
There are several interviews completed with Great War veterans. In this series, the veterans consider their various reasons for enlisting. Browse through these extracts from the archives of Radio Telifís Éireann to get personal testimony on what drove soldiers to fight.
- Edgar Poulter on joining a pals battalion at Landsdowne Road, Dublin. Extract from an interview broadcast in 1974
- Denis Kelly on joining the Irish Guards in 1914. Extract from an interview broadcast in 1981
- Jack Campbell on joining the British Army. First broadcast 1988
- ‘Emmet Dalton remembers: joining up’ First broadcast 1978
You can browse the primary evidence available at Bureau of Military History Witness statements and consider the various reasons given for joining the Irish Volunteers, the IRA or other organisations.
Also, consider the fluidity of mobilisation in either of the following Bureau of Military History Witness Statements:
Denis Dwyer, Cork. (Military Archives of Ireland, BMH, WS 713) Dwyer joined the Irish Volunteers in 1915, served in Loos, Ypres and at the Somme, and returned to Ireland and re-joined the Irish Volunteers.
What were the instincts that recruiting posters encouraging enlistment during 1914-18 appealed to at the time? Browse a range of recruiting materials in the Trinity College Dublin Digital Collections using the search term ‘recruiting’ and consider what it says about people’s motivations to fight.
Browse through some of the following British Pathé newsreels for another perspective:
‘Answering the nation’s call – Ireland’s young men rally at the recruiting office’, 1922. Film id 404.09
Finally, consider the view expressed by this pro-Treaty handbill about those who were taking the anti-Treaty side in 1922.
- ‘This is where he was in 1921…’ National Library of Ireland
What have you learned from these primary sources about the motivation to fight among people of this period? Has anything surprised you?
© Trinity College, University of Dublin