Contact FutureLearn for Support
Skip main navigation
We use cookies to give you a better experience, if that’s ok you can close this message and carry on browsing. For more info read our cookies policy.
We use cookies to give you a better experience. Carry on browsing if you're happy with this, or read our cookies policy for more information.

Skip to 0 minutes and 15 secondsBy the end of the week, you'll be able to evaluate arguments as good or bad using this diagram, but don't worry, the next video will explain how to read it. Before watching it, you need to acquire some more skills. One important skill is to be able to create counter examples to show that arguments fail logically. A counter example is in principle easy to understand, but it's a lot harder to be able to create them. For that, you need a lot of practise, and we have a lot of exercises to help you learn it. If you can come up with a counter example to an argument, then you know immediately that the argument is bad, because it fails logically.

Skip to 0 minutes and 56 secondsIf you can't create a counter example, then you need to inspect the truth of the premises. It's at that point that you start considering what the premises are about, if they make sense and whether they are true. If you can satisfy yourself that the premises are true, perhaps because they are backed up by good sub-arguments, then you know that you have a good argument. If a premise is false or if it's not backed up by a good sub-argument, then the argument is bad. There are further complications that involve irrelevant premises, but we'll show you how to identify and cope with them. To get your hands dirty with arguments, I would like you to evaluate a bunch of them.

Skip to 1 minute and 36 secondsTo be good at it, you need a lot of practise, but once you get the hang of it, you'll be a kick ass critical thinker.

Good and bad reasoning

An argument is good if it succeeds logically (that’s what we learnt last week) and if the premises are true. Otherwise, it’s bad.

By the end of the week, you will be able to evaluate arguments as being good or bad. In particular, we will help you to:

  • Create and use counter examples to show that arguments are invalid or weak.

  • Identify irrelevant premises.

  • Distinguish between sound and cogent arguments.

  • Evaluate arguments as being good or bad.

Share this video:

This video is from the free online course:

Logical and Critical Thinking

The University of Auckland

Course highlights Get a taste of this course before you join:

  • Pohutukawa tree case study
    Pohutukawa tree case study
    video

    When is it best to express your views by providing reasons? Are there cases in which other ways of expressing yourself might be better suited?

  • Arguments for and against the existence of God
    Arguments for and against the existence of God
    video

    John Bishop and Patrick Girard from the University of Auckland discuss deductive and non-deductive arguments for and against the existence of God.

  • Irrelevant premises
    Irrelevant premises
    video

    When is a premise irrelevant in an argument? Watch Patrick Girard explaining how to identify irrelevant premises in arguments.

  • Random controlled trials
    Random controlled trials
    video

    Scientific processes guard against common obstacles to good logical and critical thinking. Perhaps the most powerful is the random controlled trial.

  • Clever Hans: cuing and the observer effect
    Clever Hans: cuing and the observer effect
    article

    Hans seemed to have the maths skills of 14yr old, but O. Pfungst noticed that the horse’s handlers were inadvertently cueing him when to stop tapping.

  • Analogical reasoning in the law
    Analogical reasoning in the law
    video

    Judges egal cases use analogical reasoning to decide which similarities between cases are important.

  • Being a good ethical reasoner
    Being a good ethical reasoner
    article

    What does good ethical reasoning about such matters involve? Mainly, just good logical and critical thinking skills focussed on ethical issues.

  • Going Vegan
    Going Vegan
    video

    A pretty wild exchange for and against becoming vegan. We'll use it to see how the skills you've learned during the course can be put into action.