Want to keep learning?

This content is taken from the UNESCO UNITWIN Complex Systems Digital Campus & The Open University's online course, COVID-19: Pandemics, Modelling, and Policy. Join the course to learn more.
Man in a mask in a railway station concourse area

Do Face Masks Protect?

Should members of the public wear face masks?

Face masks could be one possible way to reduce R0 but whether or not the general public should wear face masks is a controversial issue. The question is confused because

  • there are different kinds of face masks - clinical and others

  • the benefits can be for the wearer of the mask or others

  • stocks could be taken away from front line workers

  • there no definitive study showing clear benefits

For the purpose of this discussion it will be assumed that the question is whether or not members of the public should wear ‘non-clinical’ face masks. This includes simple masks produced commercially and do-it-yourself masks made of cloth and elastic bands.

The consensus is that these masks provide little or no protection to the individual. It is said that these masks cannot protect uninfected people from the fine droplets that can travel up to two metres when an infected person coughs or sneezes. This is because the aerosol droplets have a diameter less than the mesh of the fabric.

The www.healtheuropa.eu website says that

Coughing and sneezing produce a “muzzle velocity” of 50 m/second (for sneezing) or 10 m/s (for coughing), rendering the two-m protection zone of little assistance without an additional barrier in the form of a mask.

Arsalan Karim, Director of Research and Development of Clinova, explains: “Right now, there’s a lot of talk about different kinds of protective masks, and which one is best. While surgical masks protect against infectious agents transmitted by droplets, they do not protect against airborne infectious agents such as viruses, so they will not prevent the wearer from being potentially infected by COVID-19.” [1]

This article does not cite any scientific evidence.

The World Health Organisation advises against people wearing masks. A short video and text on their web site makes their position very clear.

If you have cough, fever and difficulty breathing you should wear a mask and seek medical care. If you do not have these symptoms you do not have to wear masks because there is no evidence that they protect people who are not sick.

However, if you are healthy but you are taking care of a person who may be infected with the new coronavirus then you should wear a mask whenever you are in the same room as that person. And remember, if you choose to wear a mask use it and discard it properly and clean your hands with alcohol hand rub or soap and water.

Before putting on a mask, clean hands with alcohol-based hand rub or soap and water. Cover mouth and nose with mask and make sure there are no gaps between your face and the mask. Avoid touching the mask while using it; if you do, clean your hands with alcohol-based hand rub or soap and water. Replace the mask with a new one as soon as it is damp and do not re-use single-use masks. If you wear a mask, then you must know how to use it and dispose of it properly. [2]

So the WHO says there is no evidence that masks protect people who are not sick. It does not commit itself on the impact of wearing masks on R0 but suggests that misuse of masks could be a problem.

It is very hard to find any primary sources of evidence on the contribution of masks to reducing R0. Nonetheless there are strong pressure in many countries to make mask wearing compulsory when people are in public, as we will see in the next step.

Update 8th May 2020

On 4th May the Royal society DELVE initiative published a report with the key points given as:

Asymptomatic (including presymptomatic) infected individuals are infectious. Without mitigation, the current estimate is that 40%-80% of infections occur from individuals without symptoms. Universal screening of asymptomatic SARS-COV2 in women admitted for delivery in New York City shows that 13.7% were infected, and that asymptomatic women accounted for 88% of infected individuals in the study. Of individuals who do become symptomatic, viral loads are the highest in the presymptomatic and early symptomatic phase, decreasing thereafter.

Respiratory droplets from infected individuals are a major mode of transmission. This understanding is the basis of the recommendations for physical distancing, and of the PPE guidance for healthcare workers14. Droplets do not only come from coughing or sneezing: in a-/pre-symptomatic individuals, droplets are generated via talking and breathing15.

Face masks reduce droplet dispersal. Cloth-based face masks reduce emission of particles by variable amounts, for example Anfinrud et al showed that they are almost completely eliminated. Davies et al16 showed that cloth masks filtered viral particles during coughing at about 50 to 100% of the filtration efficiency of surgical masks, depending on fabric, with absolute filtration efficiencies of 50-70%, and about 70-80% for oral bacteria. van der Sande et al showed 50% filtering efficiency for airborne particles.

This evidence supports the conclusion that more widespread risk-based face mask adoption can help to control the Covid-19 epidemic by reducing the shedding of droplets into the environment from asymptomatic individuals. This is also consistent with the experiences of countries that have adopted this strategy. [3]

Update 17th May 2020

This article has an embedded video in which a person says “stay healthy’” without and with a mask. Laser light scattering allows the spray of the former to be seen clearly. With the mask there is virtually no spray. [4]. With thanks to Gaia Dempsey.

References

[1] Stephanie Price, ‘Are face masks useful for stopping the spread of COVID-19?’, Health Europa, 3rd April 2020. https://www.healtheuropa.eu/are-face-masks-useful-for-stopping-the-spread-of-covid-19/99087/

[2] WHO. ‘Advice on the use of masks in the context of COVID-19’, View 29 April 2020, https://www.who.int/emergencies/diseases/novel-coronavirus-2019/advice-for-public/when-and-how-to-use-masks

[3] Royal Society DELVE Initiative, ‘Face Masks for the General Public’, AboutPeopleReports, May 4, 2020. An earlier version of this document was communicated to SAGE in April 2020. https://rs-delve.github.io/reports/2020/05/04/face-masks-for-the-general-public.html

[4] Philip Anfinrud, Valentyn Stadnytskyi, Christina E. Bax, Adriaan Bax, ‘Visualizing Speech-Generated Oral Fluid Droplets with Laser Light Scattering’, New England Journal of Medicine, April 15, 2020 https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMc2007800

Share this article:

This article is from the free online course:

COVID-19: Pandemics, Modelling, and Policy

UNESCO UNITWIN Complex Systems Digital Campus