Skip to 0 minutes and 1 second Do you like being told what to do? I’m guessing your answer is no. 150 governments are using nudge and other behavioural insight tactics. They use these tactics as policy levers to steer people in certain ways. These micro approaches focus effort on visible symptoms like obesity, domestic violence, and climate change. “A sole focus on instant and points that are easy to change fails to address multiple levels of influence.” As a result, blame lands on some people, and this creates further divide in our community. Solving our most wicked problems takes so much more than nudging people. Power elites cannot take the role of choice architects. “We all have a shared duty to combat society’s most wicked problems.”
Skip to 0 minutes and 51 seconds Social marketing acknowledges this crucial fact. World-leading social marketers employ tools such as systems analysis and solution co-production. These human-centred methods address power imbalances. Basically, social marketing solutions are designed with and not for people. “Strategic initiatives created in partnership offer a much better way to improve the common good,” especially when compared to limited, tactical approaches that focus their efforts on influencing and potentially controlling other people. If you think social marketing is expensive or takes too long, I challenge you to think again. “Bringing people with you is the smarter way to go. Changing the way we practise is the best way to start.”
Centering people at the heart of what we do
Care needs to be taken when embarking for the first time on change. To deliver lasting change we need to understand how a problem has come to exist and we need to know how the people, at the heart of the problem, experience it.
The need for quick fixes and expert thinking dominates change practice, creating divides in our community. To achieve change you need people to “buy in” to reach a common goal. Many approaches to change push people away. A lot of approaches to change do not offer something that people value. Other approaches to changes avoid taking on the longer term structural changes needed to support people at the heart of the problem.
Many experts operate by drawing on years of training, their own experience and the experiences of those closest to them. A consequence of this practice is that experts think they know best.
For the people
Too often people at the heart of the problem are not included in the project teams who are given funding to solve the problem. This creates a narrow view. By not including the people at the heart of the problem, programs and services are designed by experts, without an understanding of whether people at the heart of the problem would, or would not, use the strategy that is designed.
We call this designing for the people rather than with the people at the heart of the problem.
Without living the day to day experiences of the people at the centre of the problem we can never know what is really needed to solve the problem.
Marketers know this and rather than planning for people, they work together in community to develop a deep understanding. Marketing thinking works to:
- understand what products and services are meeting needs
- identify barriers preventing change
- learn where the blind spots in planning and thinking systems are
- see what gaps exist and
- so much more.
Working in partnership
In order to apply marketing thinking we must understand how and why stakeholders currently act. Marketers work to understand how people’s and organisation’s interests can be aligned with their own aims and goals. We call this mutual benefit.
Marketers also work to understand what they are competing against because direct competition, and real and perceived barriers for all stakeholders, will limit change. It is this understanding that enables marketers to identify why change isn’t occurring. By gaining a deep understanding of the people and organisations involved marketers can identify how change can be achieved.
Delivering change requires more than a nudge
When tasked with a problem marketers work to gain a deep understanding of the current system, which includes people, processes, and organisations, to learn how to effect lasting change.
To start, marketers identify the people and organisations at the heart of the problem; the ones who know best. These people and organisations are then involved in the design and implementation of the program. This inclusive practice allows marketers to better identify barriers that have prevented change from occurring.
Don’t let experts dominate
For too long we have let experts dominate. Experts lead us to believe that individuals, or people, at the heart of the problem are the ones that need to change. If expert approaches were working we wouldn’t be faced with wicked problems like obesity, climate change and social inequalities.
People experiencing the problems everyday are best placed to identify why change isn’t occurring and they can work with others to create lasting solutions that deliver change.
Tell us how you would try to understand the people at the heart of the problem that you care about? Post a comment to get feedback on your thinking.
© Griffith University