Case Study: Zoonoses Associated with Fish
In this case study we will explore zoonoses associated with fish with a particular focus on trematodea and aquaculture.
What is Zoonoses?
Zoonoses is a disease that can be passed from animals to humans, also known as zoonotic diseases. Animals can carry harmful micro-organisms such as bacteria, fungi, parasites and viruses. These can then transfer to humans through direct contact or through food, water and the environment and cause illness. Zoonotic diseases range from mild to severe.
Zoonoses and Fish
The taxonomic group that makes up fishes is the most diverse group of vertebrates worldwide. Historically, fishermen and fish handlers represented the human population exposed to fish zoonoses. However, the growth in aquaculture, i.e. the farming of seafood, has led to an increase in published cases of fish borne zoonotic cases since the 1950’s. Additional reasons for this increased growth include: new and improved diagnosis methods; increase in raw fish consumption; and globalisation of the food chain.
In particular, foodborne diseases caused by helminth parasites (parasitic worms), transmitted by fish and shellfish products pose major public health problems. Some of these parasites are highly pathogenic and the consumption of infected raw, undercooked or inadequately preserved fish will cause human infection.
The fish borne parasites come from three main groups (Table 1). Of these, trematodes are of most concern based on the morbidities of the associated diseases.
Table 1: The three main groups of fishborne pathogens
|Main Groups||Fish Borne Parasite|
|Trematodea includes flukes and flatworms||Opisthorchiidae and Heterophyidae|
|Nematoda or Roundworms||Anisakidae and Gnathostomidae|
|Cestoda or tapeworms||Diphyllobothridae|
Trematodiasis is the infection of humans by tematode parasites. It is a serious public health problem in Asia and South East Asia, where approximately 90% of world aquaculture production occurs. Of particular concern are infections by species of the family Opisthorchiidae, the liver flukes.
The ultimate host is man or other animals feeding on fish. Human infection takes place through the consumption of raw, under cooked or under processed fish containing the infective stage of the parasite.
Generally, infections by liver flukes are asymptomatic, but high levels of infection and chronic infection can cause damage to the liver and the bile duct epithelium. This can result in gastrointestinal problems and bile duct cancer (cholangiocarcinoma).
Prevention and Control
Illness due to fish borne pathogens is the result of the consumption of raw or minimally processed/cooked fish. The incidence of disease would be reduced or eliminated if consumption of such products ceased. However, this is not feasible given the popularity of traditional fish dishes, including raw or lightly processed fish e.g. sushi.
At present protection methods involve:
Utilizing uninfected feed sources
Identification and treatment of sick individuals
Consumer education campaigns
Preventative mass medication
These methods have proved successful in a number of countries, including Japan and Korea. However, in countries where the disease is an epidemic (e.g. Asia), they are not suffice. One of the main reasons for this is the popularity of the risky products in its raw or lightly prepared forms, and thus continuous consumption and re-infection. Ideally the goal would be the production of parasite-free fish.
A review by Santos and Howgate, 2011 argues aquaculture can achieve this goal. Aquaculture practices may directly impact the prevalence and persistence of fish borne trematode. Freshwater fish are commonly raised in ponds which are suitable habitats for snails. Snails are known intermediary hosts which carry the parasite. The use of untreated animal or human manure to fertilise the water can also contain the parasite and contribute to the numbers of trematode eggs in the water. Without good sanitation habits and efficient control measures the incidence of food borne disease from trematodes will continue to increase, particularly in the countries where the disease is an epidemic.
Control of the parasite requires control over the culture practices and environment. There are several stages in the life cycle of trematodes where control could be applied. A structured and systematic assessment of the complete production system is required to identify where control can be applied.
Hazard Analysis Critical Control Point (HACCP) principles to fish culture offers this and helps ensure the safety of farmed fish at risk of infection with zoonotic fishborne parasites.
HACCP is one of the most widely used risk based tools for developing food safety management programs. It involves seven key principles:
PRINCIPLE 1: Conduct a hazard analysis.
PRINCIPLE 2: Determine the Critical Control Points (CCPs).
PRINCIPLE 3: Establish critical limit(s).
PRINCIPLE 4: Establish a system to monitor control of the CCP.
PRINCIPLE 5: Establish the corrective action to be taken when monitoring indicates that a particular CCP is not under control.
PRINCIPLE 6: Establish procedures for verification to confirm that the HACCP system is working effectively.
PRINCIPLE 7: Establish documentation concerning all procedures and records appropriate to these principles and their application.
If you would like to learn about HACCP in more detail a link to FAO’s guidelines for application have been provided here and in the “See Also” section below.
What we would like you to do
Please share your thoughts on fish zoonoses in the comments below.
Have you heard about parasitic worms transmitted by fish and shellfish products before?
Do you think HACCP is a reasonable approach and do you know of any other biosecurity measures which may be useful in ensuring parasite-free production of fish?