Skip to 0 minutes and 22 seconds SPEAKER 1: This is the story of a mother called Mrs X. Mrs X could have come from anywhere, but she is most likely to have come from a low income family in a poor country. Mrs X represents a universal mother.
Skip to 0 minutes and 44 seconds Mrs X died in the small hospital eight months pregnant. The doctor had no doubt about the cause of her death. A haemorrhage. Her placenta had been too low down in her uterus and hadn’t been identified in time. The doctor recorded her death, closed her file, and added it to a growing stack of similar cases locked away in a cupboard. Over time, these stacks grew and grew. Some years later, worried about the high numbers of mother’s dying in their hospital, the staff reviewed the cases to learn lessons and make the improvements. They reopened and reviewed file after file. One of these was that of Mrs X. When they read it, they found two striking points.
Skip to 1 minute and 35 seconds First, Mrs X had arrived at the hospital bleeding heavily, yet she only received half a litre of blood. This was all the hospital had available, and it was not enough. Second, Mrs X and her baby needed a caesarean section, but resources were limited, and the operation took place three hours too late. Both Mrs X and her unborn baby died. The group then visited Mrs X’s village and spoke with her family, neighbours, and community leaders. They found that there were other reasons for her death. Mrs X had a history of bleeding early in pregnancy but wasn’t aware that this was a danger sign needing attention. She also had had only one antenatal visit.
Skip to 2 minutes and 22 seconds If she’d gone regularly, her problem may have been picked up. She would have been referred to a specialist, and she and her baby could have survived.
Skip to 2 minutes and 37 seconds Mrs X was also severely anaemic, so the loss of even the smallest amount of blood, as little as a cupful, could have tipped the balance between life and death.
Skip to 2 minutes and 49 seconds The team discovered that it had taken six hours to collect enough money to pay for her transport to the hospital. As a result of these findings, the hospital improved their blood supplies, updated their emergency procedures, and caesarean sections could now be performed as soon as it was necessary.
Skip to 3 minutes and 12 seconds The local health department provided more midwives in more places to enable more women to have access to good maternity services throughout their pregnancy and birth. Mrs X’s file was closed again.
Skip to 3 minutes and 30 seconds A year later, a group of visiting health professionals came to the hospital as part of a national inquiry into maternal deaths. They wanted to understand what lay behind the statistics, beyond the numbers, and discover the wider social and economic reasons for the deaths of women like Mrs X and their babies and what could be done about it. The aim of their work was to recommend changes to the national or regional policies and strategies, to improve women’s health, and to save mothers’ lives. When they reviewed all that data, common patterns emerged. They found most mothers’ stories were similar to that of Mrs X.
Skip to 4 minutes and 8 seconds Like many women in developing countries, Mrs X worked day and night to care and provide for her family. She was illiterate. She lived in poverty in a remote village. She was unable to choose when and if to become pregnant. Mrs X was also weak and unhealthy. In her society, the male members of the family came first in the queue for food, for education, and for health care. Mrs X often went without. For women like her, death or complications in pregnancy were, and still are, a real threat.
Skip to 4 minutes and 53 seconds By uncovering the stories of women like Mrs X, the national team were able to put pressure on the government to provide more education for girls, more resources and staff for maternity care, and better reproductive health services. They also pushed for raising community awareness about health, nutrition, family planning, and the benefits of skilled maternity care.
Skip to 5 minutes and 18 seconds Mrs X started on the pathway of her pregnancy exhausted, with few physical reserves. She hadn’t chosen to become pregnant. It was her destiny. The only value she had to her family and community was her ability to produce children. However, Mrs X had been lucky, in a way. At least she’d had a childhood. In some societies, girls are married off while still children themselves, not physically or mentally prepared for childbirth or motherhood.
Skip to 6 minutes and 2 seconds If Mrs X had been treated as an equal to her brothers while she was growing up, she could have been healthier and better educated. If she’d had more control over her adult life, she may have been able to choose when she had children. As Mrs X continued her walk through pregnancy, her prospect’s would’ve been better if she visited a skilled professional health worker, a midwife, or doctor. Even if Mrs X had known the importance of antenatal care, her midwife was many miles walk away. If only Mrs X’s problems had been recognised and her anaemia treated. If only she’d had specialist care in time.
Skip to 6 minutes and 58 seconds Because of tradition, poverty, and lack of knowledge many women in Mrs X’s community gave birth at home. Some told stories of being treated harshly and disrespectfully by hospital staff. Some were expected to pay bribes. Mrs X had also planned to give birth at home, but then she developed a life threatening complication. She started to bleed.
Skip to 7 minutes and 34 seconds If Mrs X been referred and had transport in time to go to a hospital with facilities for providing comprehensive emergency obstetric care, such as equipment, well trained staff, and enough medicines and blood, her life and that of her baby might have been saved.
Skip to 7 minutes and 55 seconds Mrs X could have lived to raise her children.
Skip to 8 minutes and 1 second After the long delay in finding transport, Mrs X was eventually admitted to the hospital where, due to the lack of resources, she and her baby died.
Skip to 8 minutes and 14 seconds Along the pathway of her pregnancy, Mrs X faced barriers that prevented her from receiving the care she needed. Each could have been removed. And yet, many or all of these barriers remain along the roads taken by women today.
Skip to 8 minutes and 42 seconds Mrs X could be any woman. Your sister, your wife, your mother, your daughter, you. It is up to all of us, no matter where we live, who we are, or what we do, to help remove these barriers for Mrs X and the millions of pregnant women like her. As individuals, we can lobby for better health care and equal rights for girls and women. As communities, we can make sure our pregnant women are informed and cared for. We can organise local education, support, and transport for our mothers. As health care workers, we can provide quality care in a respectful environment. And we can continue to open the files and learn the lessons from mothers like Mrs X.
Skip to 9 minutes and 32 seconds As local health planners, we can provide high quality maternity and family planning services that reach out to more women. And as politicians and policymakers, we can strengthen human rights. We can improve education for girls and women. And we can provide the resources for better, more effective health care services across the world, wherever they’re needed, now.
Why did Mrs X die?
The highly regarded animated film ‘Why Did Mrs X Die? Retold’ tells the story of a global, ‘universal’ woman’s journey through childhood, adolescence, pregnancy and delivery and highlights the reasons why this particular mother and baby died. The woman, Mrs X, could come from any background, although she is likely to live in one of the poorer countries of the world. The film shows the wide variety of health, social, human rights and community barriers she and countless other women may face and how they might be overcome.
The full version of the video is available in the See Also section, and features additional commentary from the ‘father’ of the Safe Motherhood movement, Professor Mahmood Fathalla. He explains why so many women still die “in a 21st Century world” and calls for further action to reduce the continuing tragedy of the unacceptably high number of unnecessary and avoidable maternal deaths.
The story of Mrs X links closely to concepts introduced earlier in the week, where we heard about the three delays model. Sadly, many of us know a woman who has faced delays in at least one of the three steps in the pathway to safe maternity care: delays in deciding to seek care, delays in reaching a health facility, and delays in receiving appropriate care. There are also parallels to the supply of high quality care, where the importance of clinically effective, safe and respectful care was highlighted. This is especially important in a context where demand for care is high, delays in accessing that care are low, but the final barrier to life-saving care sits within the health system itself.
In this discussion we want to hear about your examples and experiences, with a focused reflection on what action is needed to prevent this from happening to women in the future. How can Mrs X be saved? If you decide to share real examples of practice please remember that any sensitive or confidential information about an individual should be removed.
Try reading and responding to others’ comments while forming or after posting your own answer. How do their responses differ from your own? You can ‘like’ other learners’ comments or reply to them to initiate a conversation.
© London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine 2019