Case study 1: The sustainability of hand pumps in Tanzania
The WASH Project in Kagera, TanzaniaConcern Worldwide is an Irish NGO that worked with local partners in Tanzania to build 775 water points over the last 10 years. These water points included:
- Shallow hand-dug wells
- Protected springs
- Gravity distribution schemes
- Solar pumping schemes
So, how well did this project work? How was its sustainability measured?Laurence travelled to Tanzania to assess the sustainability of these water points with Concern. Given that many of the water points had been in use for a long period of time, it was important to find out how sustainable the project actually was. Given the time available for the post-evaluation, it was decided to focus on the shallow hand-dug wells (of which 480 have been installed or rehabilitated). Hence, a representative sample of 17 wells was randomly chosen for the field assessment according to the District and age distribution since installation / rehabilitation (<2 years, 2-5 years and >5 years).
Want to keep
Trinity College Dublin online course,
Achieving Sustainable Development
- Water point infrastructure
- Water point (WP) committee and users
- Other backstopping support
What were the findings?The post-evaluation showed that, while a lot of effort had been made to choose a robust pump technology for the programme (which seemed to have been validated given that only one pump was not functioning), there were issues with the siting of several of the WPs which, although still functioning, were not used by the population due to concerns about water taste and colour. Many users also reported significant problems with reduced yields in the dry season: users at six additional water points also complained that the yield from the wells reduced significantly during the dry season leading to long queues as people had to wait for the well to recharge. In these cases the local population preferred to use nearby traditional unprotected sources (see photo). This highlights the importance of considering a service delivery approach with respect to WP sustainability and also the need to develop WASH programmes at the proposal stage with some flexibility to allow the best technology to be chosen depending on local site conditions i.e. not be pinned down to an exact number of WPs of a specific technology. Photo of hand pump without water in dry season (left) and traditional water resource used instead (right). © Laurence Gill The water point committees do appear to be performing a crucial function in relation to the sustainability of the water points and the members on the committee seemed to be content with the voluntary nature of their roles. There was a clear correlation between the sustainability indices of the water points and size of population served; the more in demand the water point the more likely it is to be maintained and valued by the community, The importance of ownership with regards water point sustainability has also been suggested through the fact that each time a repair was needed, and despite the failure of the cost-recovery scheme put in place, WASH committees were able to collect enough money to perform the needed repairs. However, most committees did not really know where spare parts could be sourced from locally. From a longer term perspective, the lack of specific activities and budget in the programme targeted towards analysis and development of the supply chain and maintenance capacity, and the weakness of some of the local back stopping agencies can cause a threat to the long-term sustainability. In summary, this case study illustrates the multi-faceted challenges faced by communities to ensure sustainability – the importance of a participatory approach but also thinking of the longer term operational issues, such as the supply chain for spare parts, when embarking on such a programme.
Thinking about this case study:
- In hindsight, how could a more effective supply chain for spare parts have been promoted in this region, given the number of water points being installed?
Achieving Sustainable Development
Our purpose is to transform access to education.
We offer a diverse selection of courses from leading universities and cultural institutions from around the world. These are delivered one step at a time, and are accessible on mobile, tablet and desktop, so you can fit learning around your life.
We believe learning should be an enjoyable, social experience, so our courses offer the opportunity to discuss what you’re learning with others as you go, helping you make fresh discoveries and form new ideas.
You can unlock new opportunities with unlimited access to hundreds of online short courses for a year by subscribing to our Unlimited package. Build your knowledge with top universities and organisations.