Game Design Values
Game Design Values
By Annakaisa Kultima and Alyea Sandovar
Abstract
This article proposes and explores the concept of game design value, utilizing three design theory frameworks: Holm’s design values, Lawson’s guiding principles, and Schön’s appreciative systems. Game design, like other design fields, is affected by designers’ personal attitudes, beliefs, and values. To gain a deeper understanding of the design work of game developers, it is crucial to introduce the consistency and development of these design philosophies to the field of game development. The proposed framework assists in organizing future research into game design values.
Introduction
Three decades after the debut of Pac-Man, the game industry’s success as a multibillion-dollar industry showcases the influence of digital games on social culture. As the creation of digital games expanded, so have the ways in which different designers contribute to culture. Different designers influenced digital game culture and the development of games in various ways. This has not only informed the ways that game designers think of games today but has also had a large impact culturally and worldwide. Despite the known influence of game designers in popular culture, reviews of game designers’ day-to-day lives are limited as it is difficult for researchers to enter the inner sanctum of a game studio, due to game studios’ hesitancy to share company secrets and the need to protect intellectual property. It is also an investment in time for studios to invite outsiders in.
Currently, there is a focus in game studies on understanding game designers and their work. Within the field of production studies, a growing body of literature extends beyond the player and game content research to include the production cycle and game development and its respective culture. Most professional literature focuses on production processes rather than the internal process of the designer. Literature on production emphasizes the process of creation or models and technologies for successful game creation.
Understanding the ecosystem of production involves not just the designers themselves but also the wider practice of game design. Melcer et al. identified “game design” as the most used keyword in over 8,000 articles in game research between 2000 and 2014. However, this finding is difficult to interpret, as “game design” can be connected to a variety of research papers and is often included in discussions about algorithms or game forum studies. Kultima argues that if game studies were evaluated based on Cross’s typology of design research—phenomenology, epistemology, and praxiology—the multidiscipline of game studies has been unsuccessful in addressing the latter two areas of design research.
Values and Game Design
Since the 1990s, frameworks such as Worth Centered Design (WCD) and Value Sensitive Design (VSD) have been developed to ensure that moral and ethical values are integrated into the design and development of information and communication technologies (ICTs). In game development, Values at Play (VAP) is the leading model for inserting values into game design. These frameworks are informed by the study of information ethics (IE), which suggests that technologies include the ethical frameworks, embedded beliefs, and values of those who design them. These frameworks also provide guidelines for integrating ethical intelligence in technology development. In digital games, moral values and ethical intelligence are addressed through moral play, the ethical ecosystem of games, models and techniques, and ethical stewardship in game design.
This paper, however, departs from such explorations to propose another set of values—those that refer to the process of design itself. Kultima refers to these values as those desirable for design and suggests the term “game design values.” This concept is further explored here.
One of the models used to assist game designers in consciously transferring values during game development is Values at Play (VAP), created by Flanagan & Nissenbaum. The framework asks designers to select one to two societal values and embed those into their designs. It supplements current design practices and provides an iterative process for designers to discover, translate, and verify these values in the game. However, design research conducted in academic settings often becomes normative rather than descriptive. Therefore, more research is needed on the actual day-to-day value systems of game developers. Design is not only informed by selected societal values but by a variety of beliefs and attitudes. These values operate in the background as designers work and make decisions.
Another process supporting reflection on values in game development is Sandovar’s work on cultural narratives. This study emphasizes the internal process of the designer, not just the social process and management of creation. Sandovar proposed a method that interrogates individual game designers about their cultural values through visual methods, photo elicitation, and sketching. Independent game designers from Los Angeles and San Francisco were interviewed about their design process, background, and cultural perceptions. Designers were asked to gather images representing these aspects and then group the images thematically to represent their values. These groupings and the resulting interview narratives help better understand game designers, their values, and how the internal reflective process of the designer informs their design.
Conclusion
This article emphasizes that game design, like other design fields, is influenced by various values. These values, both explicit and implicit, play an important role in guiding designers’ decisions throughout the design process. Understanding these values will provide insights into how games are created and how they reflect the designers’ values. Future research into game design values can provide new perspectives on game design practices and help guide designers in creating more ethically informed and culturally aware games.
Introduction to Games: From Design, Art and Technology to Esports
Introduction to Games: From Design, Art and Technology to Esports
Register to receive updates
-
Create an account to receive our newsletter, course recommendations and promotions.
Register for free







