Are Video Games Art?
Are Video Games Art?
By Aaron Smuts
Abstract
This article argues that many modern video games should be considered art. Rather than defending video games through a single contentious definition of art, the article suggests that video games fit within historical, aesthetic, institutional, representational, and expressive theories of art. The paper presents reasons why some video games should be classified as art, based on these theories.
Introduction
In 2000, Jack Kroll argued that video games lack emotional complexity and, therefore, cannot be considered art. His argument sparked debates in the gaming community and led to widespread discussions about the artistic potential of video games. Despite their cultural prominence, philosophical aesthetics has largely ignored video games, making it easier for censorship attempts to gain ground. This paper seeks to answer the question of whether video games can be considered art, offering reasons based on multiple art theories.
Three Candidate Games
The article looks at three video games that have received widespread praise, to demonstrate their artistic value:
- Max Payne (2001): A noir thriller where the player controls a rogue cop on a mission of revenge. The game uses voice-over narration and graphic-novel-style cutscenes, evoking emotional engagement through a complex plot.
- Halo (2001): A science fiction adventure featuring a cyborg warrior. The narrative development is sophisticated, with plot twists and character developments that enhance the gameplay experience.
- Tom Clancy’s Splinter Cell (2002): A stealth-action game praised for its realistic graphics and life-like character movements. The game’s narrative is integrated with gameplay, enhancing immersion through suspense and tension.
These games are praised for their ability to create engaging emotional experiences, which is a hallmark of art in other mediums.
Where’s the Art?
To determine if video games are art, we first need to define where the art lies. Video games combine elements from narrative fiction, music, and sports. They are more than just interactive entertainment, sharing similarities with digital animation. In some ways, they are like art-candidate sports, where the aesthetic value of the performance matters.
Sports such as gymnastics and ice skating are often judged on aesthetic criteria, and video games can be seen in a similar light. Though video games are competitive, it does not mean they cannot be art, just as competitive sports like Greek tragedies remain classified as art.
The key difference between video games and art-candidate sports is that video games involve more than just gameplay. They feature narratives, characters, and settings, much like films or novels, making them a more complex and immersive experience.
Video Game Art: A Historical Narrative
The history of video games is intertwined with the evolution of technology-based art. Video games allow artists to engage the audience in a way that other art forms like film and literature have struggled with. The medium addresses a long-standing issue in modern art: how to make the audience an active participant in the art. Video games are the first “concreative” mass art form, where the audience (the player) contributes to the artistic experience.
Noel Carroll and Collingwood’s discussions on “concreativity” and passive audiences highlight the unique position video games hold in terms of audience interaction. Video games provide a level of engagement and artistic involvement that traditional forms of art have been trying to achieve.
Video Games and Every Major Theory of Art
This section argues that, according to many major theories of art, video games should be considered art. By examining the relationship between video games and film, we see that video games share many aesthetic goals with traditional art forms, such as narrative development, emotional impact, and immersive environments. Game designers often incorporate cinematic techniques into games, using cutscenes and visual effects to enhance the experience.
The growing recognition of video games as art is also supported by the inclusion of video game-related art in museums and the development of educational programs dedicated to game design. The aesthetic and narrative elements of video games are now being celebrated as legitimate forms of art, deserving of critical attention.
Conclusion
In conclusion, while not all video games should be considered art, there is strong evidence that many video games meet the criteria of artistic works. Video games are increasingly recognized in museums, academia, and popular culture as a legitimate form of art. With their narrative complexity, immersive environments, and aesthetic techniques, video games have proven their artistic potential.
Introduction to Games: From Design, Art and Technology to Esports
Introduction to Games: From Design, Art and Technology to Esports
Register to receive updates
-
Create an account to receive our newsletter, course recommendations and promotions.
Register for free







