Skip main navigation

Olbers’ Paradox: Problem

Olbers’ Paradox describes that the night sky should be bright. Let's see how this argument works or not.
9
Hello everyone, today we are going to talk about Olber’s paradox. This is a very simple question, but it’s very interesting. Let’s get started. In 1823, German astronomer Heinrich Wilhelm Olbers
25
asked a simple but profound question: Why is the night sky is dark? We all know the night sky is dark, right?
37
But his argument is like this: If the universe is static, static means the universe is not expanding or not shrinking. That’s what people believed at that time, and if the universe has infinite number of stars, then any line of sight would end up with a star. Well in fact, the Milky Way galaxy, our Milky Way galaxy has one hundred billion stars inside. And in the uni- in the whole universe there are galaxies like Milky Way they are one, uh, one hundred billion galaxies like the Milky Way galaxy. So there would be, there is one hundred billion times one hundred billion stars in the universe, it’s almost infinite.
83
Then, when you look at the sky, any night outside would end up with a star. Then, the night sky should be as bright as daytime. However, we don’t, we know the night sky is dark, so, why? This schematic view graph shows what I just said, in any line of sight, if you look up the side, end up with a star. Then, if there’s an infinite number of stars in the universe, the night sky should be as bright as a star like this. The argument, his argument, is like this.
119
So, we’re here on earth observing the night sky, and sometimes we see a star nearby, and then these four starts are more distant, it’s actually twice as distant as the first star, and then we see because in the more distant universe the same angle subtends more area, so we see four stars in this case. Well, the distance is twice as far so these stars are actually one-quarter of the brightness of the first one so these stars are fainter. But, in this second layer there are four stars because volume is larger. So, each one of these stars are one-quarter of the brightness, but there are four. So, in total the second layer has the same brightness as the first layer.
172
The same argument for two, for the third layer too, these stars because distance is three times more distant, these stars are one-ninth of the brightness of the first star. However, there are nine stars in this third layer, so the total brightness of the third layer is the same as the first one. And then, this argument goes continues, it goes on and goes on and goes on. If there’s an infinite number of stars any line of sight will end up with a star, so the night sky should be as bright as the daytime. However, we all know the night sky is dark, it’s like this, dark sky, not like daytime.
219
So, what was wrong in this argument, what did I do wrong, in the argument so far? So this is an interesting question to ask, so please try to discuss, and then leave your opinion in the next step.

“If there are so many stars in the sky, then the night sky shouldn’t be dark, right?”

Does this question make sense to you? This is called the Olber’s Paradox, named after the German astronomer Heinrich Wilhelm Olbers. It argues that if the universe is static (neither expanding nor contracting) and has infinitely many stars, then wherever you look at the sky, you should see a star. This suggests that the night sky should be as bright as that of daytime.

Let us watch Prof. Goto’s explanation of this paradox, and after this you will try to argue if this is correct or not.

This article is from the free online

Mysteries Of The Universe

Created by
FutureLearn - Learning For Life

Our purpose is to transform access to education.

We offer a diverse selection of courses from leading universities and cultural institutions from around the world. These are delivered one step at a time, and are accessible on mobile, tablet and desktop, so you can fit learning around your life.

We believe learning should be an enjoyable, social experience, so our courses offer the opportunity to discuss what you’re learning with others as you go, helping you make fresh discoveries and form new ideas.
You can unlock new opportunities with unlimited access to hundreds of online short courses for a year by subscribing to our Unlimited package. Build your knowledge with top universities and organisations.

Learn more about how FutureLearn is transforming access to education