Skip main navigation

Get 30% off one whole year of Unlimited learning. Subscribe for just £249.99 £174.99. T&Cs apply

What is plurilingualism?

What is plurilingualism?
A group gathered around a table
© Fauxels on Pexels

The phone rings. Itto, a German woman who lives in Morocco, picks up the phone and sees it’s her Berber husband calling. The conversation goes like this:

“Salam alaikoum, labas? Mei’ tskiirt? Is’ tanna?”
“Alhamdulillah, oui ça va. Et les enfants vont bien, was machen sie? kulshi bi’chair?”
“Willst du mit Papa reden, er fragt wie’s euch geht.” (Itto’s Journal, 2010).
What language are Itto and her husband speaking? German? French? Berber? Arabic? All four? Are they switching between languages because they haven’t mastered any of them? Or do they call upon different languages depending on what feels most natural to them? This is the view that Itto takes, saying that she and her husband “mix whatever comes easiest into our mind.” Their proficiency in each language may vary, but all four languages exist in their brain and they use each one as and when they see fit.
This is the principle behind plurilingualism, developed in the 1990s by the Common European Framework of Reference for Languages (CEFR). While multilingualism views languages as separate tools for different purposes, plurilingualism sees them as parts of a single system where different languages constantly interact. This is both a theoretical stance about how languages are organised in the mind and a practical perspective that challenges traditional practices in classrooms.
It also addresses a real-world reality: that knowing only English is often not enough in today’s globalised world. Seed (2020) writes:
“Other language proficiencies as well as multicultural sensitivities can mark employees out. These skills enable confidence in less familiar situations and domains that employees can find themselves in.”
Plurilingualism, therefore, doesn’t demand high proficiency because the type of experiences that come with knowing and learning other languages is in itself incredibly valuable.

Belonging and empowerment

Proponents of plurilingualism argue that it contributes to a greater sense of belonging and power by deconstructing traditional notions of language use. Just as we challenged the first-language speaker standard in Week 2, so too does plurilingualism. Plurilingualists recognise that the ability to use various languages at the same time demonstrates a highly developed set of linguistic skills. Far from being disadvantaged, plurilingual speakers are in fact linguistically very competent individuals (Preece & Marshall, 2020). Fleming et al. (2023) argue that:
“Plurilingualism can make a difference in terms of facilitating gains in linguistic abilities, strengthening student self-confidence, and addressing issues related to social justice.”

How can we teach and assess plurilingualism?

You might think this sounds like a good idea, but how can we teach and assess a student who uses more than one language? Indeed, teachers often have similar reservations about implementing the plurilingual approach (Galante et al., 2020). However, supporters of plurilingualism advocate for an ‘action-oriented’ approach which encourages the use of meaningful tasks where the primary focus isn’t the language, but the outcome. For example, students could be tasked with planning an outing, writing a blog or planning a festival. The Council of Europe (2020) describes this as “learning to use the language, not just learning about the language”. The evidence seems to suggest that this is an effective practice. Plurilingual students in Galente et al. (2020) were more engaged with materials and demonstrated increased self-confidence.
Seed (2020), writing for Cambridge Assessment English, provides an example of how a plurilingual exam which rewards demonstrations of “plurilingual competence” might be assessed. A Chinese-speaking candidate is completing a written assessment in which candidates have to describe an image. The candidate does not know the English word ‘dolphin’, but instead of leaving a blank space, writes the Chinese word as ‘haitun’. Seed (2020) writes:
“It is of course wrong and not an English word, but succeeds in at least making the message complete. The assessment criteria…is not focused on accuracy of vocabulary but on communicative message, and therefore does not penalise” (p. 23).

Changing the way we think about languages

Plurilingualism challenges our assumptions about what it means to “know” a language, reframing multilingual speakers as resourceful communicators who draw on their full repertoire. In educational settings, it can foster pride and belonging by allowing learners to contribute meaningfully, even if they cannot do so in a single language. That said, plurilingualism has its critics: the abundance of overlapping terminology, challenges in implementation and reluctance amongst teachers have all been noted (Piccardo, 2019). Nevertheless, the concept continues to receive attention and, at the very least, invites us to rethink what linguistic competence looks like. If you are interested, here are some resources you may wish to consult.

References

Council of Europe (2020), Common European Framework of Reference for Languages: Learning, teaching, assessment – Companion volume, Council of Europe Publishing, Strasbourg, https://www.coe.int/lang-cefr.

Fleming, D., Mbida, L., Bangou, F., Fleuret, C., Masson, M. E., Thibeault, J., & Arnott, S. (2023). Plurilingualism: A review of theory and current practice. TESL Canada Journal, 40(2), 63-76.

Galante, A., Okubo, K., Cole, C., Elkader, N. A., Carozza, N., Wilkinson, C., … & Vasic, J. (2020). “English‐only is not the way to go”: Teachers’ perceptions of plurilingual instruction in an English program at a Canadian university. TESOL Quarterly, 54(4), 980-1009.

Itto’s journal. (2010). A multilingual Life. Itto’s journal. https://ittosjournal.wordpress.com/2010/12/30/a-multilingual-life/

Lau, S. M. C., & Van Viegen, S. (2020). Plurilingual Pedagogies: An Introduction. In Plurilingual pedagogies: Critical and creative endeavors for equitable language in education (pp. 3-22). Cham: Springer International Publishing.

Piccardo, E. (2019). “We are all (potential) plurilinguals”: Plurilingualism as an overarching, holistic concept. OLBI Journal, 10.

Preece, S., & Marshall, S. (2020). Plurilingualism, teaching and learning, and Anglophone higher education: An introduction Anglophone universities and linguistic diversity. Language, Culture and Curriculum, 33(2), 117-125.

Seed, G. (2020). What does plurilingualism mean for language assessment? Cambridge Assessment English Research Notes, 78, 5-15.

© University of York
This article is from the free online

The Power of Languages

Created by
FutureLearn - Learning For Life