Skip main navigation

Can consent be determined by medical examination?

Dr Jagadeesh Narayanareddy, consent in rape, absence of injuries in rape, injuries in consensual sex.
9.5
Let’s look at, can consent for the sexual act be determined by medical examination? One of the features, in the medical examination is to look for presence of injuries. Presence may be indicative of sexual violence, the presence of these injuries, but we have to be very clear that the absence of these injuries does not rule out sexual violence. Only one third of the cases, we have injuries. So the remaining two thirds, even though there are cases of sexual violence, we will not have the presence of injuries. This lack of injuries could be due to various reasons. One, it could be because the person was unconscious.
51
This could be either because of the situation of intoxication, wherein the person was like date rape drug situation. The person was given a drink laced with some drug or alcohol which incapacitated the person and the person is unconscious. Or it could be because of a head injury, so the person is unconscious. It could also be the lack of injuries could be because when the person is overpowered. This is what happens in many a time in gang rape or gang-penetrative sexual assault. In a gang rape situation, the person is overpowered, or put into a situation of fear. So there is no resistance offered.
98
Whenever a person is put into fear of either a harm onto themselves or death onto themselves or to someone they love, so they may not offer any resistance. The other suggestion would be if a lubricant is being used. So that also minimizes the injuries. Another aspect which has to be always kept in mind, that these injuries are possible even in consensual sexual act. It could range from micro injuries, which are very often present in every consensual sexual act to that of a severe injury, particularly when it’s a situation of say masochism. If somebody gains sexual gratification on getting pain. So for that situation, there may be injuries.
145.2
And if you find those injuries in on a medical examination, even though in case of a consensual sexual act. Resistance injuries could be present in the genitals, which we normally find, it could range from an aberration or a contusion. Though presence of such injuries is not a necessity. But these injuries could also be present on the rest of the body, what we normally contributed as physical injuries. So lack of physical resistance should not be construed as consent. And this goes with, again, Section 375 IPC explanation 2 which came into force from 2013, wherein it puts out just because somebody did not offer a physical resistance, it should not be construed that they have consented to the sexual act.
206.7
So medical examination may pick up injuries, but the absence of injuries does not rule out non-consensual sexual act or sexual violence.

Can the absence of injuries rule out sexual violence? Are injuries possible in consensual sexual acts? Consequently, can medical examination determine consent? These are some critical questions which arise during investigation and trial of sexual offences. In this video, let us delve into them with Dr Narayanareddy.

In the comments section below, share a misconception that may currently exist in your legal system about the role of medical examination in determining consent for a sexual act.

This article is from the free online

Decoding Forensics for Legal Professionals

Created by
FutureLearn - Learning For Life

Our purpose is to transform access to education.

We offer a diverse selection of courses from leading universities and cultural institutions from around the world. These are delivered one step at a time, and are accessible on mobile, tablet and desktop, so you can fit learning around your life.

We believe learning should be an enjoyable, social experience, so our courses offer the opportunity to discuss what you’re learning with others as you go, helping you make fresh discoveries and form new ideas.
You can unlock new opportunities with unlimited access to hundreds of online short courses for a year by subscribing to our Unlimited package. Build your knowledge with top universities and organisations.

Learn more about how FutureLearn is transforming access to education