Skip main navigation

Systems and markets

How to translate options into results? See Hannes Weigt explain the basic principles of obtaining model outcomes.
9.9
When we talk about economic modelling we naturally talk about markets. But you will often stumble upon models that do not really have a market setting or firms making choices. But those are equally important models in energy and environmental economics. Before we go into more detail on our model design, let us therefore first get an overview of those different model approaches. By now we have seen that there are a lot of potential options to design an energy system. You can satisfy energy demand by relying on a set of fossil plants, or you can go nuclear, or maybe green, or have a mix of all of those. Basically, there’s an unlimited number of combinations how our energy supply could be designed.
66
The big question is, which of those combinations should we choose? And that is where modelling economics markets and incentives enter the stage. Here we can differentiate between a system, or a bottom up perspective, and a more market, or top down perspective. A model with a system perspective often accounts for a lot of technical detail of the underlying system, the bottom up aspect. But does not really model market structures. It aims to identify the best option out of all the possible ones. In economics we also term this the social planner perspective, or benevolent dictator basically, a virtual entity deciding what the best solution for everyone would be.
124.4
Like this. In mathematical terms, it’s just the optimum. A model of a market perspective aims to represent the incentives of the involved actors, and which choice they would take to identify the option that will emerge in the market setting. Often those models are more aggregated on the underlying technical details and focus on the choices and trade offs the actors can make, the top down view. The two approaches may sound pretty different, but you will learn that they have a lot in common, supplement each other, and often can also be transferred into each other. Let’s use all four options again as an example.
173.7
In a system perspective, you would need some criterions for the different options you can base your choice on, like costs or emissions. The social planner model would then simply identify the option with the least costs or the least emissions. From a market perspective, we could assume that firms decide about which type of power plants they want to construct. This means that you have individual actors making choices. For example, they can base their decisions on how much money they earn by selling the energy to consumers, or by accounting for the environmental impacts their choice has. We will have a look at both approaches and their relation during the course.

Last week we have seen that there are multiple options when deciding about a simple energy system’s supply. To decide which of those options is the one emerging we need some criteria to base this decision on, like costs, emissions or other factors.

Models can then be designed either with a system perspective in mind – choosing the best option based on the decision criteria – or with a more market perspective in mind – modeling market actors that make decisions based on specified criteria. Both ways are equally valid modeling approaches.

This week we will focus on the system perspective while addressing the basics of optimization models.

This article is from the free online

Exploring Possible Futures: Modeling in Environmental and Energy Economics

Created by
FutureLearn - Learning For Life

Our purpose is to transform access to education.

We offer a diverse selection of courses from leading universities and cultural institutions from around the world. These are delivered one step at a time, and are accessible on mobile, tablet and desktop, so you can fit learning around your life.

We believe learning should be an enjoyable, social experience, so our courses offer the opportunity to discuss what you’re learning with others as you go, helping you make fresh discoveries and form new ideas.
You can unlock new opportunities with unlimited access to hundreds of online short courses for a year by subscribing to our Unlimited package. Build your knowledge with top universities and organisations.

Learn more about how FutureLearn is transforming access to education