Skip main navigation

£199.99 £139.99 for one year of Unlimited learning. Offer ends on 28 February 2023 at 23:59 (UTC). T&Cs apply

Find out more

Are there really mismatches?

In this article, we reject some of the apparent cases of mismatch between vel and 'or'.
Three green leaves, one orange leaf
© University of York

Are there really mismatches between vel and ‘or’?

Let’s look at the cases again.

In cases (5) and (6) we don’t need to have exclusive ‘or’ to tell us that it’s not going to be the case that both of the plugged-in sentences are true. Their own meanings determine that. If we’re understanding ‘Bob’s shirt is red’ as ‘Bob’s shirt is wholly red’ and ‘Bob’s shirt is yellow’ as ‘Bob’s shirt is wholly yellow’, then we know already that both of those can’t be true. Insisting on building that exclusion into the ‘or’ is a kind of double counting.

Case (4) is not, in fact, a strong one. Suppose the person warned doesn’t do the thing they were warned about again, but does do something else for which a ban is the penalty. We wouldn’t think that the person given the warning had ruled out a ban in this case.

Let’s look at (2) next. This might seem like a stronger case. Suppose someone said ‘Alex is meeting with Mattie or Alex is meeting with Sarah’ to us, and then we found out that Alex was meeting with Mattie and Sarah. Wouldn’t we say that what the speaker had said was wrong — and that, given what’s going on is a factual conversation, that if they spoke wrongly then they must have spoken falsely? Doesn’t that mean this has to be a case of ‘exclusive or’—a case where the both disjuncts being true means the sentence is false?

There’s reason to doubt this.

Here we need to go back to Grice’s ideas about rules of conversation. Remember that we noted that, even in a factual conversation, something might be a bad thing to say without being false by breaking one or more of the rules without a good reason.

© University of York
This article is from the free online

Logic: The Language of Truth

Created by
FutureLearn - Learning For Life

Our purpose is to transform access to education.

We offer a diverse selection of courses from leading universities and cultural institutions from around the world. These are delivered one step at a time, and are accessible on mobile, tablet and desktop, so you can fit learning around your life.

We believe learning should be an enjoyable, social experience, so our courses offer the opportunity to discuss what you’re learning with others as you go, helping you make fresh discoveries and form new ideas.
You can unlock new opportunities with unlimited access to hundreds of online short courses for a year by subscribing to our Unlimited package. Build your knowledge with top universities and organisations.

Learn more about how FutureLearn is transforming access to education