Focus on the person: Penrose and McClelland
Edith Penrose (1914-1996)
Who was she?
Edith Penrose was an economist, best known for her 1959 work The Theory of the Growth of the Firm. She is credited with bridging the gap between economics and management theory, seeing resources - in particular, human resources - as central to the growth and success of firms. The entrepreneur is central to this model as the activities of the firm are governed by the opportunities seen by the entrepreneur.
Why is she significant?
For Penrose, entrepreneurship was a psychological predisposition in which some people where inclined to take risks in the hope of personal gain. While the economic tradition considers what we might mean by risk, the psychological tradition started to explore the type of person who might take risks or deal with uncertainty. To Penrose the entrepreneur is the one who perceives opportunities and organises the firm’s set of resources to capture potential gains. This may be a specific person, but it’s their link to overall firm performance that she was interested in, ie, they behave in an entrepreneurial way but they do so within a firm (this is called being an intrapreneur).
David McClelland (1917 – 1998)
HUP McClelland, David (1). Harvard University Archives.
Who was he?
McClelland was an American psychologist who explored why some societies develop more dynamically than others (Landström 2014). He argued that one vital component of this was an individual’s ‘need for achievement’. The personal qualities of the individual, his/her drive and motivation started to be linked to their entrepreneurial behaviour. McClelland’s 1961 book The Achieving Society prompted a new line of thinking on the subject.
Why is he significant?
The 1960s and 1970s might be characterised as an era of economic and political change, in which the role and the value of the entrepreneur gained more significance. Small businesses (as opposed to large) became a focal point for economic and political support and development. The role of the entrepreneur in this process became more prominent as researchers searched for individual entrepreneurial traits and personalities. Psychologists aim to identify differences between entrepreneurs and non-entrepreneurs with the hope that entrepreneurial characteristics could be identified and nurtured. Although it still proves difficult to link specific traits with entrepreneurial behaviour, this discussion is still current in entrepreneurship literature.
What do you notice about the way Penrose and McClelland thought of entrepreneurs compared with our earlier theorists?
Share your ideas in the comments. Explore what other learners are saying and reply with your own thoughts.
Landström, H. (2014) ‘A History of Entrepreneurship Research’. in Handbook of Research on Entrepreneurship: What We Know and What We Need to Know. Fayolle, A. (ed.) Northampton: Edward Elgar
Penrose, E.T. & Pitelis, Christos, (1959) The Theory of the Growth of the Firm 4th edn. (2009), Oxford: Oxford University Press.
© Coventry University and Deakin University CC BY-NC 4.0