Skip to 0 minutes and 15 secondsOur story starts with Pong. Now Pong wasn't the first arcade game. In fact, Pong wasn't even the first arcade game with sound. But it managed to muscle its way into the public consciousness in a way that none of its predecessors had. Before Pong came along, the domain of the video game was the university computing lab. The hardware required to run games run to tens or hundreds of thousands of dollars, and it lay beyond the reach of even the most committed of home enthusiasts. Pong turned that idea on its head. It was the machine that domesticated video gaming.
Skip to 0 minutes and 55 secondsAtari's founders, Nolan Bushnell and Ted Dabney, had hired Alan Alcorn, a young engineer that they had previously worked with at the electronics firm Ampex, and set him to work on developing a bat and ball game. Now it was important to remember that this was in the days before microprocessors, and there were no standard tools or methods for developing video games. The programming language C was only just in development at Bell Labs, and it was still a couple of years away from release. With a limited budget and no well-trodden path to follow, Alcorn took a trip to a Walgreens drugstore and bought a black and white television set for $75.
Skip to 1 minute and 42 secondsHe developed the whole game on that set and a cheap state machine, a jumble of logic chips and diode arrays. As the game came together, the team decided to add sound. Bushnell wanted the roar of a crowd with every point scored while Dabney wanted a boo and a hiss when you lost a point. Alcorn didn't know how to make either, and he was fast running out of parts on the board. So he poked around in the sync generator to try and find a suitable tone. By default then, rather than by design, the sound of video games have been defined. They were the sounds that were already in the machine.
Skip to 2 minutes and 27 secondsFollowing on from the success of Pong, Atari began work on a home video game console in 1975. And its video computer system, or VCS, launched in September 1977. Back then, memory was phenomenally expensive, tens of thousands of dollars per megabyte in fact, and so to keep costs down, the engineers devised a novel way of minimising the machine's memory requirements by working with the mechanics of the cathode ray televisions that provided the display. Cathode ray displays build up the images by firing electrons from an electron gun at a phosphorescent screen that soaks up the electrons and glows to form the image.
Skip to 3 minutes and 15 secondsThe electron gun slews from side to side and up and down dozens of times a second, but-- and that is the crucial part-- it has to stop firing as it transitions between lines to avoid overwriting parts of the display. Now nearly every console and computer uses what's called a frame buffer, an area of RAM that stores a full image of the screen display in memory before sending it in its entirety to the display. Now even for a relatively small monochrome display, the VCS would have needed a 1K framebuffer, and that would have pushed the cost of the device well beyond its target price point.
Skip to 3 minutes and 58 secondsInstead, Atari's solution was to create a graphics chip, the TIA or television interface adapter, that removed the need for a framebuffer completely by building the image directly a line at a time on the screen as its electron gun slewed from side to side, carrying out the game processing in the moments that the electron gun was turned off as it transitioned between vertical lines. The cost saving on video memory shifted the responsibility for the video display from hardware to the game code, a complex process that's still described in game programming folklore as 'racing the beam'. Now what, you might well ask, has any of this got to do with music?
Skip to 4 minutes and 49 secondsWell on this chip, alongside the display mechanism, were two independent audio circuits that were also synced to the display, whose output was multiplexed then sent to the television speakers via an RF modulator. The oscillators were basic, providing just one bit of resolution. That is the oscillator could be either fully off or fully on with nothing in between. But by sending the chip complex sequences of ones and zeros generated in real time using a simple computing device called a linear feedback shift register, they were capable of producing a wide range of different pitched and noise tones.
Skip to 5 minutes and 37 secondsThe rate at which these sequences were generated was synced to the horizontal video sync counter and then sent to a five bit frequency divider circuit, giving just 32 possible pitches. The actual frequency of each tone depended on two factors, the frequency register and the length of the bit sequence. Longer sequences increased the period of the wave and so reduced the frequency of the tone. The trouble was that although there were in principle 32 pitch values to choose from, because of the limited resolution and the relatively low master frequency from the horizontal sync of the display, most of the TIA's pitches departed so dramatically from their true musical position that they really couldn't be used.
Skip to 6 minutes and 28 secondsThe TIA was really intended more for sound effects than it was for musical expression.
Skip to 6 minutes and 41 secondsNow there's an interesting parallel to draw here with the music of the late Renaissance and early Baroque. Although nowadays we tend to tune our instruments to equal temperament, meaning that each semitone interval sounds exactly the same as every other, that's really a fairly modern invention. A few hundred years ago music would have sounded quite different. For Renaissance composers, the ideal was just intonation, a system of tuning based around the frequency ratios of the harmonic series. Now unfortunately thanks to a quirk of mathematics, it's not possible to build a consistent pitch system around it.
Skip to 7 minutes and 23 secondsAnd while it sounds mellifluous when used melodically within the I, IV, and V chords of the root key, the moment the music starts to venture further afield, it sounds dreadful.
Skip to 7 minutes and 37 secondsIn order to achieve a more usable range of consonance, some of the notes in the scale would be deliberately detuned or tempered, losing a degree of pitch accuracy in favour of a better intervallic balance overall. By prioritising different tuning goals, different tuning systems have very different tonal colours and textures as you move through the 24 major and minor keys, a feature that was showcased by Bach in his famous 48 Preludes and Fugues. Now crucially the composers of the time understood that and they worked to the strengths of the tuning systems that they used, and interestingly, a similar process happened on the Atari as the hardware limitations of the system began to directly influence the aesthetics of its music.
Skip to 8 minutes and 31 secondsDuring a presentation at the Game Developer Conference in 2011, the founder of Activision, David Crane, explained that Garry Kitchen, the developer of Pressure Cooker, calculated the nine notes that could be reasonably approximated by the VCS and marked them out on a Casio keyboard. They hired a professional jingle composer to come in and write a melody for the game using just those marked notes.
Skip to 9 minutes and 12 secondsThat soundtrack, simple as it was, really marks the beginning of the professionalisation of video game music and the role of the game composer. Before then it was just one of the tasks, alongside gameplay and graphical design and programming, that was carried out by an individual. When Activision hired a professional to write the tune for Pressure Cooker, they were acknowledging music as a core component of the video game experience and a specialist task that needed specialist expertise. That the composer was so constrained speaks volumes about the creative and technical ingenuity of those early development teams.
Skip to 9 minutes and 59 secondsAny form of media music, whether it's the underscore of a movie, the title theme of a TV sitcom, or a radio sting is shaped by the medium that it's written for. But those early gaming platforms really accentuated that fact. On the VCS, the meagre memory and the very limited capabilities of the sound chip really constrained what musicians could do. That they managed to create anything that even vaguely approached music is really quite remarkable. Now we're going to move to a discussion group. What I'd like you to do is spend a little time investigating the launch of the Atari. What sort of gaming context was the console released into? What were its main competitors?
Skip to 10 minutes and 50 secondsPerhaps most importantly of all, why do you think that the Atari succeeded when other consoles offered better graphics, better sound, and better gameplay? Please post your thoughts and spend a little time reading through the thoughts of others. What are the main themes that emerge? Can you see any parallels with other consumer devices, video recorders perhaps or later generations of consoles and computers?
The Atari VCS: The domestication of videogames
The Atari VCS was the machine that domesticated video games and established Atari as the dominant player in the gaming industry… at least for a time.
In this video, we’ll look at the birth of the VCS and examine how its hardware shaped both the sound and people’s expectations of video game music.
But the VCS wasn’t the only game in town.
Once you’ve completed the video step, what I’d like you to do is to spend a little time investigating the launch of the Atari. You can find some links to contemporary sources below that will help get you started.
What sort of gaming context was the console released into? What were its main competitors? Perhaps most importantly of all, why do you think that it succeeded when other consoles offered better graphics, better sound and better gameplay?
Please take the time to post your thoughts to the comments section, and spend a little time reading through the thoughts of others. What are the main themes that emerge? Can you see any parallels with other consumer devices? Video recorders, perhaps - consider how the technically superior Betamax format was overtaken by the more popular VHS - or later generations of consoles and computers?
© 2017, Kenny McAlpine