Total calorie intake and weight lossIn one large study, 8112 overweight adults were randomised to one of four different diets: high carbohydrate, increased protein, high protein or a high fat diet.After two years following these diets and maintaining a similar energy restriction (deficit of 3.2 MJ/day) the average weight loss remained similar regardless of the composition of each diet.This study suggests that it’s the energy deficit not the diet composition that controls the amount of weight loss.
Advantages of calorie restriction
Want to keep
Monash University online course,
Food as Medicine: Talking about Weight
When counting calorie is too difficultMany people follow diets without precisely counting calories every day. It is just too demanding and difficult. If they abandon a strict calorie-counting regime, their intake is said to become ad libitum, that is, they eat as they please while trying to restrict food intake.Without imposition of a defined energy deficit to make different diets have equal impact, many other factors can now freely influence food intake: appetite, physical activity level, food energy density, food palatability, portion size, social context during eating, food availability and also the composition of the diet chosen (protein, fat and dietary fibre content and the quality and glycaemic impact of carbohydrates).Under ad libitum conditions some studies have shown high protein diets to have advantages. The optimal ad libitum diet may however vary for different population groups.High protein diets may have good satiating and weight loss effects in healthy people but have adverse effects in people with deteriorating kidney function (eg people with type 2 diabetes).People with impaired glycaemia may do better on a Mediterranean diet with lower carbohydrate content than on a low fat diet where carbohydrate is of poor quality.
Compromise fasting solutionsIf daily energy restriction is too difficult and ad libitum intake is too relaxed can a third way be devised? Interest is growing in the alternative approach provided by intermittent fasting or alternate day fasting.In 2013, Michael Mosley detailed a popular 5:2 intermittent fasting plan in which participants restrict energy intake to 25% of normal level (fast) for two days each week and then continue to eat normally on the other five days of the week. Studies in animals suggest that alternate day fasting provides the greater degree of energy restriction and more profound metabolic effects.Results from initial trials in overweight people suggest that alternate day fasting for 8 to 12 weeks can result in a 5-6% reduction in body weight with reduction of visceral fat mass, reduced heart disease risk and preservation of lean tissue.One recent study in obese people randomised to either an alternate day fasting diet or to a diet with a daily energy deficit of 1.7MJ/day found similar weight loss with both approaches (around 8kg drop in weight) that weight regain was also similar during 24 weeks of unsupervised follow-up.Recently a further study also indicated that alternate day fasting results in similar weight loss to a diet with a daily energy deficit.
Are there long term consequences?Although alternate day fasting may be effective for weight loss, questions have been raised however, about its safety including whether fasting increases gastrointestinal disturbance, affects sleep, and impacts adversely on blood sugar levels or whether it might promote disordered eating behaviors or poor body image perception.A recent study has countered some of these concerns, with the finding that when obese patients followed an alternate day fasting diet for a period of 8 weeks, the diet reduced levels of depression and binge eating although fear of fatness remained unchanged.Adverse events reported by a few participants in this study included dizziness, constipation, water retention, weakness and bad breath.
Food as Medicine: Talking about Weight
Our purpose is to transform access to education.
We offer a diverse selection of courses from leading universities and cultural institutions from around the world. These are delivered one step at a time, and are accessible on mobile, tablet and desktop, so you can fit learning around your life.
We believe learning should be an enjoyable, social experience, so our courses offer the opportunity to discuss what you’re learning with others as you go, helping you make fresh discoveries and form new ideas.
You can unlock new opportunities with unlimited access to hundreds of online short courses for a year by subscribing to our Unlimited package. Build your knowledge with top universities and organisations.